Best Restaurants in Scarsdale, NY

Scarsdale, NY, is known for its elegant neighborhoods, charming small-town atmosphere, and thriving dining scene. With a mix of high-end establishments, casual eateries, and innovative culinary spots, the town offers an impressive variety of flavors for residents and visitors. Whether craving classic Italian cuisine, a perfectly cooked steak, fresh sushi, or farm-to-table American dishes, there are plenty of excellent restaurants in Scarsdale, NY, to satisfy every palate.

Italian cuisine is a staple in Scarsdale’s dining scene, with several restaurants offering authentic dishes crafted from high-quality ingredients.

Sapori of Scarsdale is a beloved family-owned restaurant known for its warm hospitality and expertly prepared Italian dishes. With an outstanding 4.9/5 rating, this local favorite consistently impresses diners with its inviting atmosphere and top-tier service. Signature dishes such as burrata with heirloom tomatoes, fried artichokes, and house-made gnocchi keep regulars coming back. The restaurant's elegant yet relaxed setting makes it an ideal choice for both intimate dinners and family gatherings.

Cafe Alaia is a go-to spot in Scarsdale for Italian cuisine with a focus on traditional dishes and quality ingredients. Located in Scarsdale Village, the restaurant features a cozy, understated interior that complements its menu of handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and regional specialties. Favorites include the tagliatelle alla Bolognese and the branzino. Locals return for the consistency and warm hospitality, making Cafe Alaia a reliable choice for classic Italian fare in Scarsdale.

Moscato - Scarsdale offers a refined take on Italian dining, featuring a menu that balances traditional flavors with contemporary touches. Highly rated at 4.8/5, this restaurant is celebrated for its comforting yet sophisticated dishes, including handmade pasta and expertly prepared seafood. The warm and inviting ambiance and attentive service make it a favorite among locals and visitors seeking an authentic Italian experience.

For those looking for a premium steakhouse experience, Scarsdale has excellent options offering top-quality cuts and exceptional service.

One Rare Italian Steakhouse is a top-tier dining destination for steak lovers, boasting an impressive 4.8/5 rating. Known for its prime cuts, generous portions, and high-quality ingredients, this restaurant delivers a first-class dining experience. Signature steaks, flavorful sides, and a well-curated wine list make it a standout choice for a refined evening out. The professional service and inviting ambiance further enhance the overall experience, making it one of the best restaurants in Scarsdale, NY for steak enthusiasts.

Scarsdale’s vibrant food scene also includes authentic and modern Mexican restaurants that serve fresh, flavorful dishes.

PopoJito is a hidden gem in Scarsdale, known for its exceptional food and outstanding service. With a high rating of 4.9/5, this restaurant specializes in health-conscious Mexican cuisine, using organic ingredients and gluten-free options. The flavorful menu includes grilled street corn, fresh ceviche, and creative tacos made with locally sourced ingredients. The stylish interior and welcoming atmosphere make PopoJito a must-visit spot for Mexican food lovers.

Tipsy Taco Bar offers a modern take on Mexican dining, featuring a 90% gluten-free menu and locally raised meats. As a family-owned restaurant, it prides itself on using fresh, authentic flavors while incorporating innovative twists on classic dishes. With its casual yet lively ambiance, Tipsy Taco Bar is a fantastic place to enjoy tacos, burritos, and creative cocktails in a relaxed setting.

Scarsdale is home to several highly rated restaurants offering American and fusion cuisine, with menus that combine comfort food and gourmet flavors.

Chat American Grill is a popular brunch destination with a laid-back yet stylish setting. The menu includes classic and contemporary American dishes, such as French onion soup, chicken panini, and the signature lobster cobbler salad. With its welcoming ambiance and attentive service, Chat American Grill is a go-to spot for both casual dining and celebratory meals.

The 808 Bistro blends Italian and American influences, offering an upscale yet comfortable dining experience. This award-winning restaurant is known for its innovative menu, fresh muddled cocktails, and cozy ambiance. Signature dishes include braised short ribs, fresh seafood, and handcrafted pasta. With impeccable service and a reputation for excellence, The 808 Bistro remains one of the standout restaurants in Scarsdale, NY.

Scarsdale’s culinary diversity extends to Asian cuisine, with several restaurants offering authentic flavors and innovative dining experiences.

Yeomiji is a standout Korean restaurant in Scarsdale. The menu features classic Korean dishes such as bibimbap, japchae, and bulgogi, along with a rotating selection of seasonal specials that highlight the depth of Korean cuisine. The side dishes, or banchan, are fresh and plentiful and complement the entrees well. Yeomiji also offers vegetarian-friendly options and rice-based dishes that appeal to a range of dietary preferences.

Himalaya Scarsdale is a top-rated restaurant serving Nepali and Tibetan cuisine. This Zagat’s best-rated eatery is known for its flavorful dishes, including chicken vindaloo, saag paneer, dal makhani, and beef momo. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, guests appreciate the rich flavors and authentic preparation of the menu.

Akai Lounge blends modern Japanese cuisine with a lively, stylish atmosphere. The restaurant is known for its sushi bar, creative rolls, and robata grill selections, offering a broad menu that appeals to both traditionalists and those looking for something more contemporary. Specialty items like the tuna tartare and the signature Akai Roll are customer favorites, and the lunch bento boxes offer a good variety at a fair value. It's a standout option in Scarsdale for anyone craving fresh sushi and a more energetic dining setting.

Kura Revolving Sushi Bar offers a tech-savvy, interactive dining experience with its conveyor belt sushi concept. Guests can choose from a variety of freshly prepared sushi, ramen, and tempura dishes as they circulate through the dining area. The modern approach and fresh ingredients make Kura a fun and dynamic option for sushi lovers.

For those looking for a relaxed yet satisfying meal, Scarsdale has plenty of excellent casual dining choices.

A staple in the community since 1961, Parkway Café is a classic American diner known for its comforting menu. Located near the Scarsdale Metro-North Station, it is a popular spot for breakfast and lunch. Guests rave about the fluffy pancakes, traditional sandwiches, and warm, friendly service.

Metro Deli & Catering is a neighborhood staple for breakfast and lunch, known for its fast service, generous sandwiches, and wide range of hot and cold items. The deli menu includes everything from made-to-order omelets to paninis, wraps, and classic deli sandwiches stacked high with premium meats and fresh toppings. Their rotating daily specials keep things interesting for regulars. Metro Deli is also popular for catering, offering platters and trays ideal for meetings, events, and local gatherings.

Known for its handcrafted French and Viennese pastries, rustic breads, and delicate cakes, Martine’s pairs small-batch baking with warm hospitality. Whether you're stopping in for a morning croissant or picking up a celebration cake, Martine’s delivers quality and flavor with every bite. The inviting, café-style space and thoughtfully curated display of sweets make it a favorite for locals seeking a refined yet cozy spot to indulge.

For diners who appreciate fresh, locally sourced ingredients, Scarsdale has excellent farm-to-table dining options.

Meritage offers a refined American-Italian menu with a farm-to-table approach. Operating since 2004, this restaurant is located in the Heathcote neighborhood and is known for its contemporary decor and welcoming atmosphere. Signature dishes include seasonal pasta creations, fresh seafood, and innovative small plates, making it a standout choice for a fresh and flavorful dining experience.

With its diverse and vibrant culinary scene, restaurants in Scarsdale, NY, offer something for every palate. From high-end Italian dining and premium steakhouses to authentic Mexican flavors and casual cafes, the town is home to a variety of exceptional eateries. Whether exploring upscale establishments or hidden local gems, dining in Scarsdale is always a rewarding experience.

For those looking to call Scarsdale home, the town’s excellent dining options add to its overall appeal. To learn more about real estate opportunities in this sought-after community, contact Andrea Weiss today for expert guidance on finding the perfect home in Scarsdale.